Sunday, 13 November 2016

Bernie Sanders and different progressives plot Democratic gathering rebound



Recently encouraged, populist voices of the Democratic party approached Sunday for the grassroots restoration of dynamic powers in America, to revamp the gathering and bounce back after Donald Trump's devastating triumph over Hillary Clinton in the presidential race.

Vermont congressperson Bernie Sanders, who was http://gdntmessageslt.blogocial.com/ crushed by Clinton in the Democratic essential, and Keith Ellison, a rising dynamic star and a main contender to end up the new seat of the gathering, both called for diverting of gathering endeavors far from the well off liberal tip top.

"We need to do a considerable measure of reconsidering," Sanders told CBS on Sunday. "Democrats have concentrated a lot on a liberal tip top, which has raised extraordinary entireties of cash from rich individuals however has disregarded … the average workers, white collar class and low salary individuals in this nation.

"Presently we have to make a grassroots development of a huge number of individuals who need to change this nation."

Examination Why the media must roll out atmosphere improvement an essential issue for President Trump

The nonattendance of environmental change as a main subject in the race was a disappointment of the media – and it's presently their duty to get Americans discussing it

Perused more

Sanders guaranteed to battle Trump on natural directions, and said he needed millions to crusade on compelling Republicans to activity on environmental change, which Trump has denied exists. He likewise rehashed his dismissal of Trump's battle talk on workers, ladies, neutrality and Muslims, saying: "We won't acknowledge bigotry, sexism or xenophobia."

The congressperson, who has depicted himself as a popularity based communist, conceded he may discover shared opinion on back change with Trump – if the Republican held to his assertion to be "the champion of working individuals" and has "the bravery to confront Wall Street". The congressperson additionally said he concurred with Trump on the need to remake America's foundation and redesign universal exchange bargains.

"On the off chance that he's for making an exchange approach so that corporate America begins putting resources into this nation, not in China, better believe it, we can cooperate on that," Sanders said.

In any case, he said he dreaded the administration would revert into a theocracy, with a little number of to a great degree rich individuals in control of the US monetary levers. Sanders held feedback for Democrats, also, in their reverence to the rich. He reprimanded the gathering for neglecting to welcome that normal working Americans are working longer hours for low wages, are disturbed and "stressed to death over the future era".

"Trump tapped that," he said.

Asked whether he upheld the Democratic pioneers that will now be accountable for that gathering's side in Congress, Nancy Pelosi and Charles Schumer in the House Senate individually, Sanders said: "I'm not into pioneers, I'm into building a development that changes this nation."

An African American from Minnesota, the primary Muslim to serve in Congress, and pioneer of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, Ellison is viewed as a rising star in the gathering. A year ago, he was one of only a handful couple of Democrats to truly trust that Trump could win the Republican selection – an expectation he made on a similar ABC program, This Week, drawing giggling – and he was one of most blunt supporters of Sanders in the Democratic essential.

"We ought to need to put the voters to begin with, not the givers first. I adore the benefactors and we say thanks to them. Be that as it may, it must be the folks in the hairstyling parlor's, the woman in the cafe, the people who are stressed over whether their plant will close," he said.

He said he needed Democratic gathering assets to go into preparing voters at the neighborhood level. "They must be the laser-bar center of all that we do. We have to enable them at the grassroots over this nation. That is the way we return. Also, we will return."

He declined to remark when asked whether he would look for the DNC seat, or whether he would surrender his Congressional seat to be a full-time executive, should he win it.

"I will have something to state genuine soon," he said.

Michael Moore has a 'morning after schedule' for how to spare America

Perused more

The two men's perspectives were resounded by movie producer Michael Moore, who went to a substantial challenge walk in New York on Saturday against Trump's motivation, and shot himself inside Trump Tower, where the Republican president-elect has his home and fundamental workplaces.

Moore cautioned that he didn't trust Trump would enhance the lives of a large number of the working individuals who voted in favor of him "and might aggravate them". Like Sanders, he likewise advised Democrats, saying that the rustic poor and city and rural minorities had persevered years of "considerate disregard".

He additionally approached Barack Obama to choose an exceptional prosecutor to examine FBI executive James Comey's activity late in the decision, putting another bend in the adventure of Hillary Clinton's messages.

"It should be examined how the FBI executive could meddle with a race, which I accept is not legitimate, and tip the adjust in what would have been a nearby decision," he said.

Achieving a worldwide concession to environmental change took over 20 years of convoluted transactions. Marked simply under a year prior, the inadequate yet workable Paris understanding finally built a legitimately restricting system for the guideline of cutting carbon outflows. It was to be the establishment of a managed tightening up of aspiration that would hold an unnatural weather change underneath 2C. Last Tuesday night, as one by one from east drift to west the United States went Republican red, that advance was wiped out.

Donald Trump is the primary self-proclaimed atmosphere denier to lead of one of the world's greatest emitters. Indeed, even President George W Bush, however he encircle himself with doubters, did not freely deny atmosphere science. He even dealt with a couple of supportive moves. Be that as it may, Mr Trump has swore to unpick the Paris assention. In Marrakech, where agents are meeting surprisingly since Paris, they are putting an overcome confront on procedures. However, they know the standpoint is bleaker than it has been since the crumple of the Copenhagen talks in 2009.

Mr Trump can't in a split second remove the US from the Paris accord: legitimate details implies withdrawal would take four years, in spite of the fact that he may attempt to accelerate the procedure. That, however, is simply legitimate stuff. His chilling impact on atmosphere transactions has as of now started. That is on the grounds that these discussions depend as much – if not more – on trust, great confidence and political will as they do on law and lawful process. Keep in mind, for example, that lone the structure of the Paris settlement is lawfully official, not every nation's responsibilities on nursery gas emanations.

Trust and goodwill can go far: the individual appeal hostile that President Obama propelled on Beijing when he rolled out atmosphere improvement a legacy issue prompted to the noteworthy joint proclamation without which the Paris arrangement would never have been made. The possibility of its prosperity drew the nearness of all real world pioneers to Paris for the dispatch of the discussions last December, sending an unmistakable flag to their arranging groups. Presently, regardless of the possibility that the US remains in fact a signatory for some time longer, this is lost from initiation day in January.

With a threatening US, China may cool on its responsibilities, or possibly take a harder position, as it has done some time recently. India was at that point a hesitant member and the adjustment in the US position is likely just to make its protests louder.

Amusements of "imagine a scenario where" are compelling at this stage. As representatives assembled in Marrakech, the world showed up on the very edge of a remarkable period of solidness.http://gdntmessageslt.bloguetechno.com/ The Paris understanding had come into compel inside a year of its assention, an astounding accomplishment after the strife and doubt that had debilitated all the previous gatherings and even the entire UN atmosphere prepare. Yet, now that colossal accomplishment might be broken. Ambassadors are working irately to promise nations that the takeoff of the US would not mean the end of the street and the procedure can proceed.

Furthermore, it is not just the worldwide talks. In the US, as well, more atmosphere threatening activities from a Republican-ruled Congress, similar to changes to clean vitality endowments, are on the cards, while President Obama's spotless power plan to direct power stations is under grave risk. Mr Trump's proposed pioneer of the Environmental Protection Agency is a noticeable atmosphere cynic, Myron Ebell, a man once portrayed by a senior George W Bush associate as "insane Myron".

At long last, a right-inclining preeminent court may put a brake on future lawful difficulties from ecological gatherings. Brought with Mr Trump's support for coal, US outflows may soon be back immovably on their upward track. Furthermore, on the off chance that he truly needs to "scratch off" Paris, Trump could even haul the US out of the UN system tradition on environmental change, the establishment bargain under which Paris was agreed upon. On the off chance that he did, the world would lose its worldwide gathering for making reasonable and powerful move on nursery gasses and adjusting to environmental change.

Withdrawal might be a stage too far notwithstanding for Trump, for the arrangement gives the US a seat at the table that down to earth individuals would rather hold, regardless of the possibility that they attempt to saw the legs off.

For agents in Marrakech, the main wellspring of idealism might be their years of involvement in holding the discussions together. However, they can't do it all alone. At last, it might all boil down to logically proficient Republicans in Congress. They should be the voice of the 66% of Americans who comprehend the connection between human movement and a worldwide temperature alteration – and need to break it.

I have put in 42 years pushing against a patriarchy that tries to let me know what to resemble, what to feel, who to dispute to, and that there are numerous things that I can't do in light of the fact that I'm female. The weaker sPresident-elect Donald Trump has said he wants to extradite upwards of 3 million individuals once he consents to the Oval Office, and that fencing will shape a portion of his guaranteed divider on the fringe with Mexico.

Stephen Bannon and Reince Priebus will lead Trump's White House

Perused more

In a meeting with CBS's hour, set to be communicate Sunday, Trump said: "What we will do is get the general population that are criminal and have criminal records, posse individuals, street pharmacists, where a great deal of these individuals, most likely two million, it could be even three million, we are getting them out of our nation or we will detain."

"However, we're getting them out of our nation, they're here unlawfully."

On the battle field, Trump said he would expel every single undocumented transient living in the US, assessed to be around 11 million individuals. He has focused on his yearning to oust "criminal outsiders" and said that he would extradite families "in an exceptionally others conscious way".

His remarks to CBS held back before such extremes however they additionally stood out from the expressions of House speaker Paul Ryan in a Sunday meet with CNN.

"That is not what our concentration is," Ryan told State of the Union. "We are centered around securing the fringe before we get on any movement. We are not anticipating raising an expelling power, Donald Trump's not anticipating that."

Addressing CBS in his first communicate meet since he vanquished Hillary Clinton in the discretionary school and lost to her in the prevalent vote, Trump alluded to undocumented vagrants without criminal records as "fantastic individuals". He didn't portray in detail what his approach would be toward them.

Trump utilizes Twitter to bash New York Times scope and letter to supporters

Perused more

"After the fringe is secure and in the wake of everything gets standardized," he said, "will make an assurance on the general population that they're discussing who are spectacular individuals, they're marvelous individuals yet we are going to make an assurance at that."

"Yet, before we make that assurance," he included, "it's critical, we will secure our outskirt."

The day he started his presidential crusade, Trump cautioned about Mexican vagrants who were "attackers" and "crooks", and invested weeks saying transients were "pouring in" over the fringe, despite the fact that exploration does not bolster interfaces amongst movement and wrongdoing, net relocation has stayed level for a considerable length of time, and more Mexican vagrants are leaving the US than entering it.

The US as of now has a vast foundation for capturing, confining and expelling vagrants. More than eight years, Barack Obama has extradited more than 2.5 million individuals, more than some other president, and dramatically increased the quantity of outskirt watch operators. He has additionally expanded fringe reconnaissance, and gotten the nation's biggest jail organization to confine transients.

Obama sought after migration change yet neglected to press a bipartisan bill through Republican restriction in Congress in 2013 and 2014. He in this way requested clearing official activities to shield qualified transients, generally youngsters and all without criminal records, from extradition. Trump has promised to revoke those requests.

Trump backs same-sex marriage however not premature birth under incomparable court risk

Perused more

Trump likewise talked about his approach to secure that http://www.justluxe.com/community/view-profile.php?p_id=43214 fringe, the proposed divider, which on the battle field he said would be an authentic divider made of "solidified cement", "rebar" and "steel".

Long extends of the about 2,000-mile southern fringe as of now have fencing, under a years-in length extend that has demonstrated troublesome and costly to establish.

Inquired as to whether some extends of his divider would comprise of fencing, as recommended by congressional Republicans, he said: "For specific ranges I would, however certain territories, a divider is more suitable.

"I'm great at this," the representative included. "It's called development."

It appears to be unexpected that the head administrator's trip to India (Report, 8 November) ought to concur with the Sheffield Hallam give an account of the overwhelming emptying out of UK assembling. Where have our assembling employments gone yet to inadequately paid specialists in India and China, where exploitative working conditions and kid work are overflowing? Would it be a good idea for us to not erect more duty boundaries instead of looking to expel them?

Murray Marshall

Salisbury, Wiltshire

• John Crace is on the whole correct to propose the Royal Festival Hall as a place to begin taking out "a gigantic swath of the liberal metropolitan tip top" (Digested week, 12 November). A week ago I was there watching Abel Gance's sublime film Napoleon. Close to the end, when Napoleon, alone, waxes persuasive about his vision of an Europe without fringes, the greater part of the gathering of people ejected in cheers and adulation, muffling the generally couple of boos (also the going with Philharmonia Orchestra).

Emma Brockes' companion (Notebook, 10 November) is thinking about her alternatives: Cuba or Israel. Emma may get a kick out of the chance to advise her that Israel is the nation that has officially fabricated its divider.

Like Elvis meeting Nixon, the president-elect and Nigel Farage smile, thumbs up, in the overlaid vulgarian's heaven of Trump Tower. This picture is a reward as sweet as any the between time Ukip pioneer may have sought after – sweeter, maybe, than the EU choice result itself. It adds cudgeling power to his claim to be our man in the new Washington, practically speaking if not by authority arrangement.

Concerning Trump: could there be clearer confirm that the following pioneer of the free world does not have all feeling of etiquette and strategic convention? On Thursday he schmoozed the executive, Theresa May, in a phone call, the glow of which enchanted (and eased) her authorities. There is a watched trust among her partners that she may tenderly control the 45th president towards a more practical position on organized commerce, Nato and the regulation of Russia.

In his discussion with the PM, Trump refered to the point of reference of Ronald Reagan's association with Margaret Thatcher. A more profitable motivation would be Macmillan's bond with Kennedy. In a reminder unveiled in the Sunday Times, Sir Kim Darroch, the UK's diplomat in Washington, communicated the trust that the president-elect would be "interested in outside impact if pitched right … we ought to be all around put".

I comprehend that in an unpublished area of Trump's call to May he flagged that his crusade talk ought not be taken too actually. It is justifiable that the PM respected this – who might not? – and that the administration wants to control the president-elect towards some form of rational soundness.

Be that as it may, May's group ought to deal with their desires. One can't expect from Dr Jekyll's intermittent appearance that Mr Hyde is away for good.

Still, how solid is the longing to trust that Trump is an option that is other than what he patently is – that office will mollify him and smooth his unpleasant edges, that he will be subdued by the administration. Give us a chance to call it Von Papen disorder.

Nigel Farage meets Donald Trump

Facebook Twitter Pinterest

Farage meets Trump: 'This picture is a reward as sweet as any the between time Ukip pioneer may have sought after.' Photograph: ‏@Nigel_Farage/twitter

In 1933 the German bad habit chancellor, Franz von Papen, anticipated "confining Hitler", and asserted: "Inside two months we will have pushed Hitler so far in the corner that he'll squeak." These gloats were, to understate the obvious, mixed up (however just to expect fuming Trumpist trolls: I am drawing a similarity, not recommending direct equality between the Führer and their American legend).

The stories you have to peruse, in one helpful email

Perused more

Here there is a solid parallel with the level headed discussion on Britain's takeoff from the EU. Pretty much as a few lawmakers envision that there can be a "delicate Brexit", so the daydream has emerged that the "hard Trumpism" of the crusade will yield place to a delicate Trumpism in office. However consider how the president-elect reacted when the Wall Street Journal asked him whether he had gone too far. "No," he answered. "I won." This is barely the voice of modesty.

The new unique relationship, regardless, is not between pioneers or governments. It is a threatening social ring that extends over the Atlantic associating Brexit to Trump's decision and all it forecasts. This is the thing that truly matters.

The symmetry is not correct. Practically speaking, the "left behind" had more prominent influence in the submission result than in the presidential challenge: around 66% of those with salaries under £20,000 voted to leave the EU. Conversely, a higher rate of low-pay voters selected Hillary Clinton than for her Republican winner.

Richard Nixon meets with Elvis Presley at the White House in 1970

Facebook Twitter Pinterest

Richard Nixon meets with Elvis Presley at the White House in 1970. Photo: White House/AP

Trump, besides, confronts couple of institutional requirements: his gathering controls both Congress and Senate, and he has swore to shape the preeminent court in his picture. How the Brexiteers must begrudge him, as they reel from the high court's choice that parliament must give its endorsement to the activating of article 50.

However regardless of these distinctions it is sit still to deny the beating association between the two developments. Both Brexit and Trump's race have obviously discharged the poisons of bigotry, xenophobia and homophobia.

As per the National Police Chiefs' Council, the quantity of detest wrongdoings ascended by 58% in the week after the vote to leave the EU. In July, August and September, homophobic occurrences expanded by 147% contrasted and a similar period a year ago.

In the US a comparable example is stating itself: Muslim young ladies are startled to wear the hijab. The trademark "Gay families blaze in damnation!" shows up over the hashtag Trump2016. The swastikaThe divider that Donald Trump has guaranteed to expand on the US-Mexico fringe may to some extent "be some fencing", the president-elect said in a meeting discharged on Sunday, as the top Republican as of now in Washington indicated at contradictions and instabilities for how they mean to oversee together.

My trips in Trumpland

Perused more

In a meeting with CBS's hour, Trump said "there could be some fencing" in his proposed divider, which would traverse almost 2,000 miles and cost billions. On the battle field he guaranteed that the boundary would be only worked of "solidified cement", "rebar" and "steel".

"I'm great at this," he told CBS. "It's called development."

Likewise on Sunday, Paul Ryan, speaker of the House and the official ready to compose clearing new enactment for the Republican-controlled government, said he trusted his gathering had "a command" to reshape social insurance, duties, directions and fringe security for the Trump organization.

Inconsistencies between Trump's guarantees and Ryan's arrangements, notwithstanding, recommended that the president-elect and his future Congress don't yet know how they will roll out such improvements.

Ryan demanded, for example, that Trump's "need" would not be the mass expelling of a huge number of undocumented transients.

"That is not what our concentration is, we are centered aroundhttp://gdntmessageslt.ampblogs.com/ securing the outskirt before we get on any movement," Ryan told CNN's State of the Union. "We are not anticipating raising an extradition constrain, Donald Trump's not anticipating that."

Trump has over and again guaranteed an "extradition constrain" and in August said: "The very first moment, my first hour in office, those individuals are gone!" In his CBS talk with, he said he would expel upwards of 3 million individuals.

"What we will do is get the general population that are criminal and have criminal records, group individuals, street pharmacists, where a considerable measure of these individuals, most likely 2 million, it could be even 3 million, we are getting them out of our nation or we will detain," Trump said.

"Be that as it may, we're getting them out of our nation, they're here unlawfully."

In June, Ryan broke with Trump over a proposed restriction on Muslims entering the US. On Sunday, Rudy Giuliani, one of the president-elect's guides, said the boycott would now be forced on a nation by-nation premise.

"The boycott would be limited to specific nations," the previous New York leader told CNN, naming Syria and Yemen. "All the rest from nations that contain perilous populaces, they would be liable to 'outrageous checking'."

Giuliani recommended the US could work with administrations in Egypt and Pakistan for "entirely great reviewing", yet not a total boycott.

Speaker Ryan additionally said the Republican party, which until a year ago to a great extent upheld Barack Obama's organized commerce plan with Asia, was not by any means behind Trump's guarantees to force high taxes on nations, for example, China and Mexico.

"Not taxes, not exchange wars," Ryan said, rather saying he needed to "settle our charges on fringe changes".

He kept up that the gathering would discover shared belief with the new president, saying: "He's attempting to make America more focused."

Arrangement promises analyzed: what could the following president truly do?

Perused more

Ryan resounded Trump in proposing that the gathering expected to keep a few sections of Barack Obama's Affordable Care Act, while canceling the medicinal services law itself.

A full cancelation could mean upwards of 20 million individuals losing medical coverage. Ryan told CNN that individuals 26 and more youthful could, as indicated by his proposition, remain on their folks' arrangement, and that Congress would "need an answer for previous conditions". He likewise said the gathering would propose "refundable duty credits" that "would bring down the cost" of scope.

"We would have a social insurance framework in America where everybody, paying little respect to pay and position," he said, would "get the opportunity to purchase what you need to purchase, not what the administration is making you purchase".

Be that as it may, Ryan declined to answer addresses about whether ladies would even now have the capacity to have anti-conception medication secured.

"I'm not going to dive into all the quick and dirty insights about these things," he said, including, "I'm not going to get into hypotheticals about enactment that hasn't been composed yet."

Giuliani additionally demanded that Trump would have no irreconcilable circumstances in office, regardless of the possibility that he hands control of his sprawling, universal business to three of his kids, who have gone about as his nearest counsels.

"When he gets into government they won't be – they won't prompt," Giuliani said. "There will must be a divider between them with respect to government matters."

Ryan additionally communicated trust in Trump and his escort, which incorporates Steve Bannon, a previous financial specialist and far-right media CEO whose site, Breitbart, has trafficked in transparently supremacist, sexist, homophobic and prejudiced composition.

"I've never met the person. I've never met Steve Bannon," Ryan said. "So I have no worries. I trust Donald Trump.

"I trust that Donald will have an extraordinary arrangement of decisions to make for staffing [the White House]," Ryan proceeded. "He's a fruitful individual, he encircle himself with effective individuals. So I'm certain he will do likewise here."

He decried the culprits of abhor violations and supremacist spray painting that have been accounted for since Trump's triumph, saying: "They are not Republicans and we don't need them.

"We are pluralistic, we are comprehensive, and will keep on being. I truly think individuals ought to comfort their psyches."

A huge number of nonconformists, be that as it may, have walked in urban communities over the US since Tuesday's race, which Trump won in the discretionary school however lost in the prevalent vote. The showings were to a great extent quiet, despite the fact that on Saturday police closed off an area of Fifth Avenue in New York to keep marchers far from Trump Tower.

Trump utilizes Twitter to bash New York Times scope and letter to supporters

Perused more

In Indianapolis, a few people tossed rocks at police and officers terminated pepper balls into the group. In Portland on Saturday night, police made a few captures after conflicts amongst dissenters and officers in mob outfit. Leader Charlie Hayes argued for quiet.

"For whatever length of time that challenges are serene, that is the thing that we can do in this nation, that is the thing that the main revision is about," Ryan said.

Trump has given no reasonable view about the challenges. On Thursday night he said the marchers were "proficient nonconformists, affected by the media" and "exceptionally unjustifiable!" On Friday, he said: "Love the way that the little gatherings of dissenters the previous evening have energy for our awesome nation. We will all meet up and be glad!"

Ryan has had a troublesome association with Trump, whom he met in Washington on Thursday when the president-elect likewise met Obama at the White House.

Gotten some information about his reprobation in June of Trump's "reading material bigotry", in regards to a Hispanic judge directing an extortion claim against the specialist, Ryan told CNN: "Look, I'm not going to relitigate the past. I'm looking toward what's to come."

President-elect Donald Trump came back to Twitter on Sunday morning, to assault a recognizable focus on: the New York Times.

My voyages in Trumpland

Perused more

Trump, who has spent the end of the week at Trump Tower in New York shaping his move arranges and considering conceivable organization arrangements, tweeted: "Goodness, the [New York Times] is losing a large number of supporters due to their extremely poor and exceptionally off base scope of the 'Trump wonders'."

The letter to which Trump alluded was sent by Times distributer Arthur Sulzberger Jr and official proofreader Dean Baquet to supporters after Tuesday's decision. They composed: "Did Donald Trump's sheer unpredictability lead us and different news outlets to belittle his support among American voters?"

Later on Sunday, Trump additionally said on Twitter: "The [Times] states today that DJT trusts 'more nations ought to obtain atomic weapons'. How untrustworthy are they. I never said this!"

In an examination with the Times on remote arrangement and at a CNN town corridor occasion, Trump said that a few nations, for example, Japan, South Korea and Saudi Arabia, may be in an ideal situation on the off chance that they acquired atomic weapons.

Trump's tweets were an inversion by the president-elect to the freewheeling utilization of web-based social networking which stamped a lot of his battle before diminishing in the last weeks, at the impelling of crusade staff. It additionally flagged a readiness to keep on using the press as a whipping kid.

The president-elect has long pursued the press and, specifically, the Times. In October, battle supervisor Kellyanne Conway told the Guardian Trump would document a claim against the daily paper after it distributed stories about ladies who charged that he sexually struck them. That suit has yet to be documented.

In September, the Republican candidate tweeted: "My attorneys need to sue the coming up short [Times] so severely for flighty aim. I said no (for the time being), yet they are viewing. Truly nauseating."

Donald Trump undermines to sue New York Times over 'flippant expectation'

Perused more

"Untrustworthy purpose" does not exist under any standard or precept found under US law.

Trump's antagonistic association with the press has gone pasthttp://jp.un-wiredtv.com/index.php/member/47121/ Twitter. As a presidential applicant, he long kept a boycott of outlets like the Washington Post which were precluded from being credentialed for occasions.

He additionally made assaults on the media a standard piece of his stump discourse and asked swarms at his occasions to boo and pester journalists.

In February, Trump vowed to "open up the slander laws" so that "when [newspapers] compose intentionally negative stories … we can sue them and make heaps of money�

No comments:

Post a Comment